Jeffrey Mathews is a former American football quarterback. He was most recently a member of the Toronto Argonauts of the Canadian Football League (CFL). Mathews was the quarterback of the Cornell Big Red and finished his time at Cornell ranked among the top 20 quarterbacks in passing yardage in Division I FCS history. He surpassed the Cornell record for total passing yards by more than 2,000 yards and ended his collegiate career as the holder of 47 Cornell and 18 Ivy League conference records. Matthews has also been a member of the Atlanta Falcons, Indianapolis Colts, Arizona Cardinals and Hamilton Tiger-Cats.